When It Comes to Your Microbiome, More Germs Are Better
Yes, you can be too clean for your own good
Jun 14, 2022Your Health
Deborah D. Gordon has spent her career trying to level the playing field for healthcare consumers. She is co-founder of Umbra Health Advocacy, a marketplace for patient advocacy services, and co-director of the Alliance of Professional Health Advocates, the premiere membership organization for independent advocates. She is the author of "The Health Care Consumer's Manifesto: How to Get the Most for Your Money," based on consumer research she conducted as a senior fellow in the Harvard Kennedy School's Mossavar-Rahmani Center for Business and Government. Deb previously spent more than two decades in healthcare leadership roles, including chief marketing officer for a Massachusetts health plan and CEO of a health technology company. Deb is an Aspen Institute Health Innovators Fellow, an Eisenhower Fellow and a Boston Business Journal 40-under-40 honoree. Her contributions have appeared in JAMA Network Open, the Harvard Business Review blog, USA Today, RealClear Politics, The Hill and Managed Care Magazine. She earned a BA in bioethics from Brown University and an MBA with distinction from Harvard Business School.Full Bio
Learn about our editorial policies
Yes, you can be too clean for your own good
One of the hottest topics in scientific research today is the microbiome and its effects on human health. Microbes appear to play a role in how we sleep, how likely we are to develop certain diseases and whether we’ll develop allergies — and seemingly everything in between.
The microbiome is a group of microorganisms (also called microbiota or microbes) that live in a particular environment. These microbes include bacteria, viruses, parasites and fungi, which we sometimes just call “bugs.”
Each of us has our own, unique microbiome made up of trillions of microbes that respond to whatever we’re exposed to in our environment and whatever we put in our bodies, such as food and medicine.
“The microbiome is around 40 trillion cells comprising 200-500 different species of bacteria, and they produce a cornucopia of chemicals that our body has become reliant on over the last few million years of our evolution,” said Jack A. Gilbert, Ph.D., professor in the Department of Pediatrics at the University of California San Diego School of Medicine and Scripps Institution of Oceanography.
Each part of our body — including the gut, skin, mouth and nose — has its own set of microbes living in it.
We generally associate bacteria and viruses with getting sick. And sometimes, microbes do cause disease. The virus that causes the flu and the fungi that cause athlete’s foot are just a couple of examples.
But, the microbes in our microbiome can also be incredibly helpful — even essential — to our health.
Microbes help strengthen our immune system, fight certain pathogens (organisms that cause disease), digest food and turn it into energy, and absorb certain vitamins.
Researchers have found all kinds of associations between microbiomes and conditions ranging from Alzheimer’s disease and diabetes to colorectal cancer and obesity. And they keep investigating more.
One study found that people with more diversity in their microbiomes were more likely to sleep better and longer.
Other evidence suggests that our gut microbiome interacts with our brains, potentially affecting mental health and neurological conditions. Scientists don’t fully understand the gut-brain relationship yet, but studies in animals have shown that gut bacteria may reduce stress. And a 2019 paper in the journal Nature showed that the presence of certain bacteria in humans was associated with higher quality of life; lower levels of certain bacteria were associated with depression.
“The microbiome and the immune system are two sides of the same coin,” Gilbert said. “In fact the immune system evolved as a mechanism to manage the microbial garden in your body — like a gardener, the immune system helps to maintain the growth of bacteria that produce things we need and tries to eliminate the ones that may harm us.”
According to Gilbert, any disruption in the immune system or the microbiome can have an effect on the other, sometimes leading to autoimmune disease and allergies.
There is evidence that gut bacteria can actually prevent or improve food allergies, and other studies have shown that gut microbes can affect susceptibility to and severity of autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and lupus among other autoimmune disorders.
In an ironic twist, when we try to avoid germs — like when we douse ourselves or our kids in antibacterial hand sanitizer — we may actually be doing more harm than good.
The hygiene hypothesis is the idea that when an environment is too clean, our immune systems don’t learn to ward off infections as well as they could.
As the author of the book “Dirt is Good: The Advantage of Germs for Your Child's Developing Immune System,” Gilbert argues that most exposure to germs is good for kids and that parents should even give a pacifier that falls on the floor back to their baby without sanitizing it first.
But Gilbert also said it’s not too late for adults to get the benefits of exposure to diverse microbes.
“While early-life exposure can have profound impacts on the developing immune system, we believe that continual exposure to diverse sources of microbes throughout life still provides benefits,” he said.
Gilbert points to gardening as a way adults can diversify their microbiomes.
“We have found bacteria in soil that can have an anti-depressant effect through immune stimulation, as well as animal-associated bacteria that may improve lung function,” Gilbert said. “[This is] all very early work, but it points to potential benefits for adults, especially as you grow older.”
Just like our bodies have a unique microbiome, so do our homes and workspaces. These indoor environments are called the indoor microbiome, which is made up of the same kind of microorganisms found in our bodies, such as bacteria and viruses.
In the “Wild Life of Our Homes” study, which analyzed household dust from more than 1,100 homes, researchers found that indoor microbiomes were more diverse than outdoor ones, influenced in part by who and how many people occupy the space.
If you’re a neat freak or a germaphobe dedicated to ridding your home of dirt, microbial diversity may sound like a nightmare when you realize it means many different types of bacteria, viruses and fungi are coexisting with you.
But it turns out, a little dust and dirt won’t necessarily hurt you, and it may even help you.
Take, for example, households with dogs. Dogs are notorious for sniffing everything and stepping in all kinds of substances outdoors, and then tracking that dirt inside.
But instead of trying to control the dirt your dog brings home from his or her routine walks, you may want to embrace it. Studies show that babies who interact physically with dogs have a 13% reduction in the likelihood of developing asthma. (Exposure to farm animals was even better.)
So should everyone get a dog to improve their microbial diversity and the protective qualities of their indoor microbiome? Gilbert might say yes.
“From a microbiome standpoint, [dogs] are a valuable source of immune simulation, as their bacteria activate our immune system and keep us healthy,” Gilbert said. “So yes, you should rescue a dog.”
So instead of shying away from a slobbery dog and hunting down all the dirt they bring in, consider the contribution the germs are making to your health. And instead of racing to beat the five-second rule if a piece of food falls on the floor, just eat it.
Your body will probably thank you.