The treatment you receive depends on the type of thyroid disorder you have, what's causing it and your overall medical condition. In general, there are three categories of treatment: prescription medication, radioactive iodine and surgery (thyroidectomy).
Hypothyroidism
Hypothyroidism, including Hashimoto's thyroiditis, is the simplest of the three types of thyroid disorders to treat. It requires a daily dose of prescription synthetic T4, called levothyroxine sodium (L-thyroxine, L-T4). You and your health care professional will work together to find the right dose for you based on your symptoms and blood tests.
You'll need to take T4 for the rest of your life, although the dose may change. You will also need periodic blood tests to evaluate the dose.
Many years ago, the only treatment available for hypothyroidism was desiccated thyroid, the dried and powdered thyroid glands of animals. It contains both T4 and T3. While desiccated thyroid is still available today, few health care professionals advocate this "natural" therapy. Desiccated thyroid produces variable blood levels of thyroid hormones, not the steady and predictable levels needed for optimal health.
If your T4 dose is too low—if you remain somewhat hypothyroid—you may experience symptoms of hypothyroidism (depression, low body temperature, dry or itchy skin, poor memory, muscle aches, slowed reflexes, among other symptoms). If your dose is too high—if you become somewhat hyperthyroid—you may notice symptoms of hyperthyroidism (nervousness, weight loss, fast or irregular heart rate, changes in appetite, insomnia, muscle weakness or fatigue, decreased menstrual flow, among other symptoms). Over time, TH excess can increase your risk of an abnormal heart rhythm or osteoporosis.
In the United States, levothyroxine is available as four branded products (Levoxyl, Levothroid, Synthroid and Unithroid) and several generic versions. All of the branded and generic preparations contain the same hormone—levothyroxine—and are effective in treating hypothyrodism. However, because the preparations may differ in the amount of levothyroxine they contain, many experts have expressed concerns about potential adverse effects caused by switching between manufacturers as will happen with the generic T4 preparations. For example, the 100 mcg dose of one preparation may contain the same amount of T4 as the 112 mcg dose of another preparation, so switching between preparations may actually represent a dose change.
Generally, you should stick with one T4 product for treating hypothyroidism, generally a branded T4. However, because of insurance issues, you may not have a choice between branded or generic. If possible, stick to one generic manufacturer to keep the level fairly consistent in your body. If you must change generics or brands, talk to your health care professional—he or she may have to repeat your blood tests and change the dose to maintain the desired effect or prevent toxicity.
If you do switch brands or change to a generic T4, you should have your TSH level checked six weeks later. In general, because multiple manufacturers produce generic versions, those on generic T4 should have their TSH levels monitored more frequently.
Hyperthyroidism
If you are diagnosed with hyperthyroidism, including Graves' disease, your health care professional will consider several factors to determine the best treatment for you. These include your age, your general health and the cause and severity of the hyperthyroidism. Available treatments include I-131 radioactive iodine (the form of radioactive iodine that damages thyroid tissue), antithyroid drugs and surgery.
A dose of radioactive iodine works to damage the thyroid gland, ending the hyperthyroidism. After the iodine is administered, the gland shrinks and blood levels of TH drop. In most, the hyperthyroidism is completely resolved within three to six months. The main side effect is the development of hypothyroidism. Occasionally, you may develop a sore throat one or two weeks after the treatment.
Some people with hyperthyroidism receive antithyroid drugs such as propylthiouracil (PTU) or methimazole (Tapazole). These drugs are designed to interfere both with the thyroid gland's uptake of iodine and with one or more of the steps required for the thyroid to make TH. Because iodine is essential for TH production, reducing the amount of iodine the thyroid gets reduces the amount of TH it produces. Some people with Graves' disease may go into a long-term remission of more than a year after one or two years of treatment, after which the drugs are stopped.
Surgery to remove part of the overactive thyroid gland is occasionally recommended to treat hyperthyroidism. Like radioactive iodine, people who undergo surgery usually become hypothyroid. Complications include damage to the parathyroid glands that control the body's calcium levels and damage to the nerves that control your vocal cords, leading to hoarseness.
Since any of the three treatments for hyperthyroidism can lead to hypothyroidism, it's important that you learn to recognize the symptoms of too little thyroid hormone: depression, low body temperature, dry or itchy skin, poor memory, muscle aches and slowed reflexes. Let your health care professional know if you experience any symptoms.
Nodules
If a nodule is benign—as most are—it will probably simply need to be monitored, not treated. If a biopsy is unclear or identifies a malignancy, then you will need a thyroidectomy, or removal of all or part of the thyroid.
A thyroidectomy is performed under general anesthesia and takes about two hours. If the biopsy showed a malignancy, the surgeon usually removes the entire thyroid and some surrounding lymph nodes. If the biopsy was unclear, the surgeon may remove just one lobe of the thyroid and, while you're still under the anesthetic, wait for it to be tested for cancerous cells. If these cells are present, the surgeon removes the other lobe. If the cancer has spread outside the thyroid, the surgeon may also remove the lymph nodes in your neck.
If you have thyroid cancer you may require treatment with a large dose of the I-131 form of radioactive iodine about six weeks after surgery to destroy any remaining cancerous tissue. The use of radioactive iodine in thyroid cancer has changed in recent years and is beign used less frequently. This is because many patients with small cancers, who are at low risk for cancer recurrence, do not appear to benefit from radioactive iodine since they are most likely cured with surgery alone. You should discuss this with a thyroid cancer specialist. You also begin lifelong TH replacement therapy. In most cases, the surgery and radioactive iodine cure the cancer.
As with other surgery, the minor risks include infection, bleeding and scar tissue on the neck. Major side effects from surgery are rare and involve complications to neck structures close to the thyroid, including damage to the parathyroid glands that control your body's calcium levels and damage to the nerves that control your vocal cords, leading to hoarseness. These complications, however, occur in less than 1 percent of patients operated on by experienced surgeons. If the parathyroid glands are damaged during surgery, you'll need calcium supplements and possibly other drugs.