womenTALK: Blog

Thursday, Feb 04th 2010

What To Eat After Exercise (It Matters)

authored by Sheryl Kraft

The other day after my workout I headed to a local Starbucks. I was craving a soy latte, something I used to drink every day but cut down to once or twice a week after realizing that it was really cutting into my budget. As I was waiting for my drink, I eyed the pastries in the glass case, fantasizing about what it would be in my next life. I'd go to the gym and sweat it out, followed by a leisurely visit to AnyCoffeeShopUSA and order a large latte to wash down my big, sweet slice of banana chip bread/blueberry scone/or any other gooey, sugar-laden treat. Guilt-free, I'd sit and relax, munch away and revel in the joy of it all.

But then I snapped back into reality when I heard an enthusiastic voice behind me. "I'll have a Venti Vanilla Latte with whipped and a piece of the blueberry coffee cake," she shouted, loud enough for the passing cars to hear. Maybe it was nosiness on my part, or just an instinct I couldn't resist (aren't those the same two things?), but I turned around to see who was ordering that. My fantasy: one of those impossibly skinny-no-matter-what-she-eats women who defy all logical rules of metabolism. The reality: A woman I recognized from the gym. "Hey," she said to me, throwing up her hands without any degree of self-consciousness, "I deserve it, I just worked out!"

So, here's the stark reality of the situation, I wanted to say. But I'm not that type of person; I keep things to myself unless I'm asked for my opinion. Okay… you're all probably asking me at this point (I'll just assume that, since I can't hear you - but fantasize that you are). what is the reality?

You can't eat anything you want just because you've worked out. Not only will it negate the calories you burned, but most of us overestimate how much we really do burn when we work out. It's usually not as much as we think. Sorry. Chances are the calories you take in will be much more than what you burned, making you scratch your head and wonder why, if you are so diligent at the gym, you're gaining weight, anyway.

And here's some more reality (you asked, didn't you?) WHAT you eat after exercise can make a difference on your body's metabolism. You need to replenish your energy sources. Since many of the health benefits of aerobic exercise happen with the most recent exercise session as opposed to the cumulative effect of exercise, a new study says that the nature of these benefits are influenced by the food we eat right after our workout. How? Exercise enhances insulin sensitivity (meaning that it's easier for the body to take up sugar from the blood stream into tissues like muscles, where it can be stored or used as fuel). And this benefit is more likely when you eat foods that are relatively low in carbohydrate content.

Before you sigh over yet another study, here's some good news that came out of this one: you don't have to starve yourself after your gym session to get some real health benefits. Even if you don't lose weight, they say, you're still reaping he benefits of increased insulin sensitivity you get from exercise.

Some expert carb suggestions are oatmeal, brown rice, grains like quinoa or amaranth, and all vegetables and fruits.

I'm off to the gym now...and packing a cheese stick to munch on so I'm not tempted to order that tempting-looking piece of low-fat cake that's calling my name like a flashing neon sign.

Comments

Feb 09, 2010 11:Feb 11 | Lizette Reyes said

Im a Group Fitness Instructor

Im a Group Fitness Instructor and on the days I teach, since I do 2 classes back to back, I have a bigger lunch & good snack before the workout. After the classes one of my favorite snacks is cottage cheese,sprinkle w/cinnamon, a LITE drizzle of organic honey and what everfruit..ras/blue straw berries, bananas, etc etc...cottage cheese is high in protein and this mix is YUMMY!! :)

Feb 10, 2010 10:Feb 10 | Sheryl said

Thanks for your tip, Lizette.

Thanks for your tip, Lizette. Sounds yummy and packed with the protein necessary for post-exercise.

Feb 07, 2010 14:Feb 2 | Jennifer Margulis said

I like healthy eating

It always makes me feel so much better than low-fat cake and other sugary sweets. Especially after exercise. I'm going to do some right now (fussy baby does not want me to be writing blog comments) and eat something yummy and healthy afterwards. No vanilla cream puffs for me!

p.s. the captcha here is have hotcakes!!!

Feb 08, 2010 13:Feb 1 | Sheryl said

I agree, Jennifer. Eating it

I agree, Jennifer. Eating it tastes good, but then there's that crash and burn feeling afterwards.

PS. Have hotcakes? Hmmm, is there a message in that? How funny.

Feb 06, 2010 12:Feb 12 | Jennifer Haupt said

This is very interesting and

This is very interesting and something I've wondered about. Thanks, Sheryl. Very good advice.

Feb 05, 2010 18:Feb 6 | sarah henry said

i've been having breakfast

i've been having breakfast every saturday after dance class with a group of gals for more years than i care to remember.

we used to do the croissant or scone and latter shuffle, lately we seem to have all switched to yogurt, fruit, and granola. tides me over for hours. and it's super delish too.

Feb 08, 2010 13:Feb 1 | Sheryl said

What a nice way to spend your

What a nice way to spend your Saturdays, Sarah. With a dance class and then breakfast to look forward to (and such a healthy one..)

Feb 05, 2010 17:Feb 5 | Almost Slowfood said

I'm like that lady!! However,

I'm like that lady!! However, I am trying to limit my treats these days.

Feb 05, 2010 13:Feb 1 | Frugal Kiwi said

Sad but true

You are spot on as usual. But I still WANT that scone.

Feb 08, 2010 13:Feb 1 | Sheryl said

THanks - and that temptation

THanks - and that temptation never seems to go away, now does it??

Feb 05, 2010 13:Feb 1 | Alexandra Grabbe said

I don't know as I'd go for

I don't know as I'd go for the cheese, but an apple sounds good.

Feb 05, 2010 12:Feb 12 | MyKidsEatSquid said

String cheese is one of my

String cheese is one of my post-workout staples too. I notice that I crave protein--not carbs. I read somewhere a long time ago the skim chocolate milk was a great post-workout replenisher. Can't remember all the reasoning behind it, probably had something to do with the protein, but I've also tried that too. Oatmeal after a workout? Hum, that just doesn't sound, well, satisfying. Have you tried it?

Feb 05, 2010 17:Feb 5 | Sheryl said

Does an oatmeal cookie count

Does an oatmeal cookie count :)? No, haven't tried the bowl of oatmeal yet, but am going to...I do think it will fill me up just fine!

Feb 04, 2010 18:Feb 6 | Susan Johnston said

Very true! But sometimes it's

Very true! But sometimes it's nice to indulge a little. :) I like that Starbucks has tiny pastries now for $.75, so I can get a few bites of something sweet without completely blowing my diet!

Feb 05, 2010 10:Feb 10 | Sheryl said

Susan, I've never seen these

Susan,
I've never seen these tiny pastries...I wonder if they're in all Starbucks, or I just haven't seen them because I try to avoid looking and being tempted??

Feb 04, 2010 13:Feb 1 | Harriet K. said

When I work out, which is

When I work out, which is quite often, I always have an apple and a cup of tea afterwards. After doing a great amount of physical activity, I can't eat anything heavy anyway and I'd feel guilty for negating my work-out.

People should defintely take your advice and remember.

Great post!

Feb 04, 2010 16:Feb 4 | Sheryl said

Thanks for writing, Harriet.

Thanks for writing, Harriet. Sounds like you're on the right track with you frequent workouts and healthy snack afterward. Wish I liked tea more, but coffee is my hot drink of choice...

Post new comment

If you do not wish to leave your name, please leave the "name" field blank.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.